By Tayyar Ündüci
The following saying may today be perceived as a way of paving the way to selling products at high prices, but on closer inspection it carries deep meaning:
The English proverb holds that one is not rich enough to buy cheap goods.
For the last 8–10 years, an ‘everything is done, projects included’ trend has been running wild. Software packages are believed to be the cure for everything. People with no grounding in engineering, design or structural detailing think they have solved every issue once they enter the data the software asks for. Worse still, we have trader-minded investors who proceed with this logic even in large plant investments. Our words are not directed at our industrialist investors. If you ask what the difference between a trader and an industrialist is: the trader chases short-term gains, while the industrialist pursues long-term gains. The industrialist does not live for the moment.
What is engineering? What is a project? What is plant installation? Those who set out without knowing these have either ended in disappointment or become owners of shanty-like operations, busy spending time, money and energy solving a new problem every day.
Software packages, and using them, will not solve all your problems. For example, if you do not have a competent engineering project team before a plant installation (with its process already resolved):
- Having the software select the equipment will not resolve all the components in line with the process fundamentals. If you are not familiar with the equipment and its operating principles, product sellers will try to sell you the equipment that suits the conditions of the day. But will you have bought the optimum equipment you need? Afterwards you will be digging a well with a needle.
- If you cannot lay out the plant to suit the topography of the land and the weather and natural conditions, you will get lost in labyrinths.
- Calculating the power requirement of auxiliary equipment (conveyors, elevators, pumps, valves, etc.) with software (by entering the data the program asks for) will not resolve all system components.
- When calculating a steel structure with software, simply finding the member cross-section (by looking at the green-red colours) will not resolve all the components.
- Calculating reinforcement with software will not resolve all the reinforced-concrete structural components.
- Having the software perform the stress analysis will not resolve all the piping components.
- Performing the insulation calculation for the structure (which is not done on many jobs) will not resolve all the cladding components.
And so it goes on.
When the fee for engineering and project services is written into a quotation, people’s hair stands on end and it becomes the first item to be crossed out. But the trading spirit peculiar to our country has found the solution.
“Everything is done, project engineering services included!”
Looking back at the years before 2000, project engineering services were an entirely separate sector; today they are intertwined with manufacturing and installation. With the rise of software packages and the growing number of young unemployed technical university graduates (from so-called universities), engineering and project services are being trampled underfoot. Everyone is a project designer, everyone is an engineer, everyone is a designer. We have nothing against individuals and companies who do their work properly. But project engineering services are not that easy either.
Project engineering should be a service that optimises the investor’s requirements and lowers operating cost items. Saying ‘I built the plant, the structure, the equipment, and it is still standing’ is not enough. What did it cost? What are your operating expenses? What is the state of your maintenance and repair costs? How many man-hours does it take to run? And so on. The starting point for all of these lies within the scope of project engineering services.
If you have given a job to a company whose main business is manufacturing, with project engineering services included (thinking no fee is being paid for project engineering), get ready to watch a horror film. Especially if you have set out on a lump-sum basis, the chances of getting a sound return in terms of quality and service are very slim. If you have set out with unit prices, hitting the budget, quality aside, is also unlikely.
Did these kinds of problems not exist in the past as well? If they had not, I suppose the picture below would not have entered our archive years ago.

But with today’s education and technology, minimising these has become so simple. That is why project engineering services (including technical specifications) must be a separate company and/or group independent of the manufacturing group. We have manufacturers, investors and contractors who have achieved this and who still have very valuable project engineering groups in-house. Look at successful investors and contractors. They are companies that draw their leadership and infrastructure from project engineering-based knowledge, blend it, and move forward without ever lumping manufacturing and project together.
There are many examples, past and present: investments, plants and equipment that have become toys in the hands of the manufacturing group. The only cause of such failures is of course not the manufacturers. In fact, the root lies in the logic of buying the work, the project, whatever we call it, more cheaply from a single sector. In other words, the trader’s logic. The project company will do the project. The manufacturing company will do the manufacturing. The civil engineer will not do the mechanical engineer’s job, the architect will not do the civil engineer’s job, and the surveyor will not do the geotechnical engineer’s job. The purchasing function will not go out to any flawless purchase without a technical specification. Above all, everyone will do their own job. There will be an organisation to manage these disciplines. First, mindsets will change. Believe me, we will then channel our energy and money into other productive avenues. We will use our time better and devote more time to our families and loved ones.
So let us put an end to the fairy tales of “Everything is done, project engineering services included!”













